Top 10 Black-Owned Food Spots in Sanibel & Ft Myers, Florida

by Gabby Beckford
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Support Black-owned restaurants in the Sanibel, Cape Coral, Ft. Myers, Florida area? on your vacation—start with this list!

If you’re in the area, check out the following spots:

McCarter's BBQ

Just east of downtown Fort Myers, Florida, McCarters' BBQ serves some life-changing ribs. Locals call it “Willie’s” even though its proper name is McCarter’s BBQ. But the funny thing is, the food is so good that they don’t advertise.

There isn’t even a sign on the building, as you can see below.

Google Maps Image McCarters BBQ
Here's an image from Google Maps—a true diamond in the rough.

If you don’t know what you’re looking for you would never even know it existed, but if you were lucky enough to investigate, you'd be pleasantly surprised by their earth-shaking ribs which have more than 200 5 star reeviws on Google!

2675 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33916


Jonesez BBQ

For 11 years Jonesez BBQ has been serving up great food through the generations. By generations, I mean the multiple generations of family members who have helped in the business!

Owners Andre and Vickie Jones have recruited both nephew Caleb Jones and niece Savara Jones, as well as Andre’s parents, Remus and Nekia Jones into the business.

50 Pine Island Road, Fort Myers / 1840 W. State Road 80, LaBelle


Spice Caribbean Bar & Grille

Looking for huge portions, and vegan options? Spice Caribbean Bar & Grille is the place for you.

Jerk chicken, goat soup, and Jamaican beef patties, with an affordable price and an abundance of take-home containers—trust me, you'll need them!

3380 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd., Fort Myers


Want to support Black-owned restaurants in the Sanibel, Cape Coral, Ft Myers, Florida area? Start by digging into these top local eateries! Click To Tweet

Beach Brothers BBQ

Black-owned and operated by Stan and Susan Peoples, Beach Brothers BBQ was once a brick-and-mortar eatery, but they've taken their show on the road via food truck!

They share their location & menu details on their Facebook page, and can often be found hanging around No. 3 Craft Brew & Beer Bar.

1319 Cape Coral Parkway, Cape Coral


Irei-I Jamaican American Cafe

Opened in 2017, seeing this spot warmed my soul as I knew my father and grandparents—all Jamaican as well—would love to eat here.

With homemade cultural staples such as curry goat, red snapper, and beef patties on the menu, it's easy to imagine you're in a restaurant somewhere in Kingston eating the food of the island!

3559 Fowler St., Fort Myers


Deep South BBQ

I visited Deep South BBQ because it was so conveniently located on the way back to Cape Coral from J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge on Sanibel Island. Little did I know that I would find a personal connection—owner Albert Houston served in Operation Desert Storm with the Marine Corp at the exact same time as my own father!

Knowing that I was supporting not only a Black-owned but veteran-owned business, made their pulled pork, shrimp, and garlic blue crabs that much sweeter.

3500 Fowler St., Fort Myers


Chelle's Special Touch

Click to view

Visit Chelle's Special Touch, where the menu changes daily but the food is always guaranteed delicious! She has unique dishes such as crab-stuffed salmon, mahi-mahi, stuffed eggplant pasta, and shrimp chipotle salad.

The best part? Owner Michelle Pope has made almost everything from scratch since the opening in 2018. Order takeaway, delivery, or catering to feed your whole family!

2855 Work Drive, Fort Myers



@fibrre on Instagram

Smoothies, smoothie bowls, veggie burgers, and other fit foods are served inside Fibrre by owner Adenike Johnson!

Located inside of the LA Fitness at Gulf Coast Town Center, you'll find healthy food that tastes as good as it makes you feel.

10058 Gulf Center Drive, Fort Myers


Labadie Bar Restaurant & Bakery

When is the last time you had authentic Haitian food? If ever?

Well, today's the day to visit owners Ronald and Aline Cadet at Labadie and sample some Caribbean favorites such as kalalou, rice and pikliz, and whole fish stew. Mmm!

Fly Foods owner Tiffani Banks is not only a small, Black, woman-owned business but a staple of the community. Click To Tweet

3580 Evans Ave., Fort Myers


This post was sponsored by The Beaches of Fort Myers & Sanibel.

 Will you be visiting the Fort Myers and Sanibel area soon? Which Black-owned spots will you hit first? Let us know in the comments!

Gabby Beckford

You may also like

Leave a Comment