Why Neutrality is Just as Harmful as Prejudice

Peace

In light of recent events in the United States, I feel compelled to say the following. As abhorrent and horrifying the violence and discrimination in our country is, I find another problem equally as disturbing.

As many rally in support of those affected by these social issues, there are still those who sit quietly. Those who may believe in a cause or have an opinion, but choose not use their voice. Those who believe it’s too much trouble to get involved or subscribe to a label such as “LGBTQ ally”, “feminist”, or “equalist”.

If I could speak to the population who agrees with that passive ideology, I would simply say: It must be nice.

Christie Basinas, American in Paris

Christie Basinas, one of the few Americans in Paris on the day of the Pulse Orlando shooting. A normal citizen, choosing to speak as an LGBTQ woman to the Parisian people as an American.

It must be nice to not have to know what the term feminism means. It must be nice to never have to worry about earning 23 cents less per dollar than someone else solely because you were born with different reproductive organs. It must be nice to never have to send your friends your location when you go on a blind date and check in with them once an hour, or else they’re to assume something’s gone wrong. It must be cool that people assume you’re more capable, less emotional, and more intelligent. It must be nice that your genuine feelings of disappointment, shock, or anger aren’t tossed aside with a “you’re being crazy” or “are you on your period or something?” comment.

It’s pretty neat that you’ve never been called the N-word by other classmates in the lunch line at school. To never have been told, “Stop talking like you’re white”. It must be nice to never have been asked questions about black celebrities, just because you’re supposed to know because you’re black too. To never have been asked, “Where are you from? No, I mean, like, really from?” or “What are you?” It must be nice that people don’t use quantifiers to describe you like, “She’s so beautiful! …like, for a black girl.” It must be nice to not care the difference between the words ethnicity, race, heritage, nationality, and culture. To have your culture constantly insulted, humiliated, deemed lesser, and appropriated all at the same time. It must be fun to have preferred physical traits.

It must be nice.

Must be nice to never have been petrified to tell your crush you liked them because you thought they’d call you disgusting. It must be nice to never have been called a faggot, dyke, or fairy. It must be nice to never have been avoided in functional, private settings like the bathroom, the locker room, or the gym, because people of the same sex assume that you’re, like, preying on them. It must be nice to never have come to the realization that you’re sexual preference doesn’t fit the term “hetero-normative”, and have to worry about the effect that your preference will have on the rest of your life. It sounds so relaxing that you’ve never lied to your best friend, parent, teacher, or peers just to avoid the awkward glances.

No To Islamaphobia

Anti-Islamaphobia sign held at a rally in London, England.

It must be nice to never have been told to go back to where you came from. To be told you hope Donald Trump becomes President so you can be sent back to the desert, when you were born in Boise, Idaho. To never have to change the way you dress because you may be attacked simply for wearing an article of clothing. It must be cool to be able to be able to converse in your native tongue without people eyeing you or even moving away from you. It must be nice to be able to tell someone to go fuck themselves, or scream or cry or just defend yourself in public without carrying the perception of your entire community on your shoulders.

Don’t for one second believe that passiveness is any less detrimental oppression. If someone is extremely prejudiced, at least there exists a chance that they’re just ignorant and wrongly educated about someone. But claiming that you “don’t want to subscribe to a label” implies that you are well aware of an injustice and you are actively choosing to not participate in the correction of that injustice. Inaction is an action.

Desmond Tutu articulated this best when he said,

“If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor. If an elephant has its foot on the tail of a mouse and you say that you are neutral, the mouse will not appreciate your neutrality.”

You should especially reflect on this if you’re choosing neutrality because a certain issue doesn’t impact you directly. It’s a privilege to be able to ignore these injustices. You are privileged if your life is so unaffected by these issues that you are able choose to roll over in your bed, ignore them, and still sleep soundly at night.

And yes, you can be discriminated against and still discriminate against others—you can be latino and not care about LGBTQ+ rights, and you can be Muslim and not care about gender equality. This is especially insane because… you know. You know it feels to be put down or treated differently, and you find no qualms in passing on that ignorance to another human being? Just because you may be fighting a battle of your own doesn’t mean you’re exempt from defending another brother or sister.

Obama Quote

“I don’t have the luxury of just not doing anything and then being able to stand back and feel as if my conscience is completely clear” Image by AJ+, click image for link to credit.

If you have chosen to be passive up until this point, I understand. The world we live in scary, and if you have the option of course its easier to ignore these things things than to willingly walk into the fray. And I’m not telling you to start burning bras or getting in altercations, but now more than ever is the time to take stand up and take action. Participate in work to change certain legislation. Vote. Defend someone who you see is being put down. Do something.

Take action for your mom, whose ideas and thoughts deserve to be acknowledged as equal. For your professor, who shouldn’t be disrespected based on the faith he chooses to follow. Stand up for that kid in middle school who you used to say had “cooties” because he came to class with his nails painted. Stand up now, so you don’t regret sitting in silence later.

Half-hearted support is damaging because it encourages the idea that you can say something but not really mean it.

Believe me—it is not the thought that counts.

Credits: Header image by Shawn Semmler

 


Related Posts

5 Discussion to this post

  1. This is such a passionate and emotional post. Thanks for having the courage to write this and share with the world. I am sure many people will appreciate it. I hate confrontation but will always try to say something if I hear a racist or sexist or xenophobic comment made. It’s not always easy – I’ve had raging debates with my brother about feminism (he later told me I was right) and severed a few friendships due to blatant racism and islamaphobia. As much as it makes me feel uncomfortable to say something – I know that I couldn’t live with myself if I didn’t. I think each voice can make a difference and agree that passive acceptance can be dangerous. Thanks for sharing!

    • Gabby says:

      I feel exactly like you do Chantel! I definitely don’t want to run around telling people their opinion is wrong or starting fights or anything in that nature. But the people who see someone reach out for support and choose to to not get involved or put their opinion out there “because it’s too much trouble” really shock me. I couldn’t live with myself either! Everyone can, and should, do something to help each other. 🙂

  2. Lauren says:

    This is so exquisitely written! It really is necessary for people to SPEAK UP, especially in the private sphere. When you allow things to slide, it makes people think oppression is okay. The instructions for being an ally are pretty clear. Most people just don’t want to deal with the uncomfortability of confronting blatant truths. Thank you so much for sharing- pinning meow 🙂

    • Gabby says:

      Thanks so much for your kind comment Lauren. I totally agree. Staying silent is easy. Speaking up is brave, and defending what is right should be what we both strive for! You’re obviously one of the good ones! 🙂

  3. Yamuna says:

    I couldn’t agree more! For instance, it’s far too often that I hear some women nonchalantly say, “oh, I believe in equality but I’m not a feminist.” And I’m like, “Do you even KNOW what you’re saying..?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *